Introduction
It’s extremely important to have an active antivirus while searching the web, providing you security from malware that can feast on your private data.
Fortunately, Microsoft Windows’ default antivirus is very effective at protecting your PC. But if you fancy additional features and finer control over your security settings, then there are a few fantastic paid-for options too.
Our team of experts test a variety of antivirus to see which provide the best malware protection and range of features. We’ve also taken cost into effect, with an eye on nasty renewal fees that can provide an unwelcome surprise after the first year of subscription.
Those paid-for antivirus that impressed us the most have been included in this best list, so you know for sure that you’re getting great value for your money.
And if you’re not bothered about getting premium features, then we also recommend checking out our best free antivirus options. We even have options for the best VPN and best password manager for you to peruse.
If you’re not ready to make an antivirus purchase just yet, then make sure to check back here, as we’ll be updating this list on a regular basis as we publish more reviews and continue our testing.
Best antivirus at a glance
- Best overall: McAfee Plus Advanced – check price
- Best mid-priced: G Data Total Security
- Best short-term: Norton 360 Advanced – check price
- Excellent protection, with ethical concerns: Kaspersky Internet Security – check price
How we test
For raw performance against malicious software, we use data from multiple testing houses: AV-Test, SE Labs and AV-Comparatives. Of these tests, we prioritise ‘real-world’ performance, in which antivirus detection engines are exposed to live threats.
We also draw on system performance data captured by AV-Test and we inventory and compare features on an application-by-application basis, highlighting both useful tools and unexpected sticking points in the workflow and interfaces.
- Accurate malware detection
- Clearly highlights auto-renewal options
- Wide range of useful tools
- Price increases upon subscription renewal
- May conflict with UK government security guidance if you’re a remote worker in specific sectors
- Perfect malware protection
- Wide range of features
- Includes full VPN
- 200GB of online backup storage
- High false positive rate in some tests
- Expensive renewal rates
- Excellent malware protection
- Wide range of tools including a decent VPN and password manager
- Unusually comprehensive identity protection and recovery service
- Expensive
- Steep price increase after first year
- Excellent malware protection
- Wide range of security and system optimisation tools
- Out of date system tuner, parental controls and password manager
McAfee Plus Advanced
Best overall antivirus
Pros
- Excellent malware protection
- Wide range of tools including a decent VPN and password manager
- Unusually comprehensive identity protection and recovery service
Cons
- Expensive
- Steep price increase after first year
If you’re looking for an antivirus that offers absolutely everything, from top-notch security to a myriad of useful features, then we recommend McAfee Plus Advanced.
Its malware protection proved to be excellent in lab tests, achieving perfect scores from SE Labs and AV-TEST, while blocking 99.80% of malware for AV Comparatives. It also rarely falsely identified legitimate software and websites as being harmful, resulting in one of the best all-round antivirus performances we’ve seen.
But McAfee Plus Advanced really excels with its feature offerings, as you can install it on an unlimited number of devices, make use of its kill switch and use a cleanup service that stops online data brokers selling your private data.
You also get a password manager and VPN bundled into the package, and while neither are the absolute best in their respective fields, they still get the job done competently.
The main sticking point for McAfee Plus Advanced is the price, as it’s one of the more expensive antivirus offerings. But if you want a comprehensive antivirus package with lots of useful features, this is the one to get.
Reviewer: K.G. Orphanides
Full review: McAfee Plus Advanced Review
G Data Total Security
Best mid-priced antivirus
Pros
- Excellent malware protection
- Wide range of security and system optimisation tools
Cons
- Out of date system tuner, parental controls and password manager
G Data Total Security is a mid-price antivirus, which offers a superb malware-blocking performance and a decent selection of features.
It was one of the very few antivirus to achieve a perfect 100% score in both the AV-TEST and AV Comparatives, and so provides great peace of mind while browsing the web. That said, it was a little too militant for our liking, with a high number of false positives showing that it’s prone to blocking legitimate software.
There are a number of useful features here, including parental controls, performance tuner, encryption tools, secure file shredder, USB device access control, and a dedicated firewall – you even get a password manager thrown in for good measure. But some of these features feel outdated, while the client is very retro.
With this in mind, we still think McAfee offers the better overall package. But since G Data Total Security is more affordable, it’s still a great option if you don’t want to spend a fortune on an antivirus package.
Reviewer: K.G. Orphanides
Full review: G Data Total Security Review
Norton 360 Advanced
Best short-term antivirus
Pros
- Perfect malware protection
- Wide range of features
- Includes full VPN
- 200GB of online backup storage
Cons
- High false positive rate in some tests
- Expensive renewal rates
Norton 360 is really good at protecting you against malware, but recent test results indicate that it might also try to “protect” you against some legitimate software, as well. In the latest SE Labs real-world malware exposure tests, it protected against 100% of infections, with no false positives. Two months of testing by AV-TEST was almost the same. However, although it detected 100% of malware in the most recent AV Comparatives real-world test, it also falsely identified 26 legitimate applications
Norton 360 Advanced covers ten Windows, macOS, Android or iOS devices and includes a firewall, webcam protection, parental control, silent protection mode, password manager, full Norton Secure VPN subscription, 200GB online backup storage, Dark Web Monitoring and School Time distraction management tools to lock down unauthorised programs for children engaged in remote learning.
Features unique to the Advanced subscription tier include Identity Restoration Support, where NortonLifeLock staff will help you resolve issues with banks and merchants if you’re the victim of identity theft. Meanwhile, Social Media Monitoring watches over you or your children’s Facebook, LinkedIn, Twitter, YouTube and Instagram accounts for scams, inappropriate content, impersonation or harassment.
It’s a fantastic selection of features only rivalled by McAfee. But those steep renewal fees make it difficult to recommend for the long term. And so we only really recommend Norton 360 Advanced if you just need an antivirus for a year at most, as you can get some bargain offers for the first 12 months from third-party retailers such as Amazon.
Reviewer: K.G. Orphanides
Full review: Norton 360 Advanced review
Kaspersky Internet Security
Excellent protection, but ethical concerns with Russian links
Pros
- Accurate malware detection
- Clearly highlights auto-renewal options
- Wide range of useful tools
Cons
- Price increases upon subscription renewal
- May conflict with UK government security guidance if you’re a remote worker in specific sectors
It’s difficult to unequivocally recommend Kaspersky Internet Security right now, even though it provides some of the most accurate malware protection you’ll find.
With much of its threat research and some of its business operations in the Russian Federation at the time of the country’s invasion of Ukraine, Kaspersky rapidly moved its international business operations to its UK holding company and its threat analysis to its Zurich data centre.
However, at the time of writing, when you click agree on Kaspersky’s EULA and other agreements, you’re still making a legal agreement with “AO Kaspersky Lab, a company incorporated according to the laws of the Russian Federation.” That presents ethical issues for those uncomfortable with the fact that Kaspersky provides services to the Russian government and military. Remote workers in certain sectors may be affected by NCSC guidance.
If none of that bothers you, then Kaspersky’s consistently good performance continues to impress. The company’s software is frequently discounted, and you can find great retail deals. If you subscribe online, higher renewal costs are clearly signposted and it’s easy to avoid auto-renewal.
Reviewer: K.G. Orphanides
Full review: Kaspersky Internet Security
FAQs
Not really. Windows has Microsoft Defender built in, which is one of the most competent antivirus protection available. But opting for third-party paid-for antivirus software will unlock a greater range of features, such as password managers, parental controls and more.
Both forms of antivirus can detect and block malware, but paid-for options can unlock additional features such as VPNs and advanced parental controls.
You might like…
Editorial independence
Editorial independence means being able to give an unbiased verdict about a product or company, with the avoidance of conflicts of interest. To ensure this is possible, every member of the editorial staff follows a clear code of conduct.
Professional conduct
We also expect our journalists to follow clear ethical standards in their work. Our staff members must strive for honesty and accuracy in everything they do. We follow the IPSO Editors’ code of practice to underpin these standards.
Editorial independence
Editorial independence means being able to give an unbiased verdict about a product or company, with the avoidance of conflicts of interest. To ensure this is possible, every member of the editorial staff follows a clear code of conduct.
Professional conduct
We also expect our journalists to follow clear ethical standards in their work. Our staff members must strive for honesty and accuracy in everything they do. We follow the IPSO Editors’ code of practice to underpin these standards.